This fully-resourced lesson describes the conversion of glucose to pyruvate during glycolysis in the cytoplasm and produces ATP and reduced NAD. The engaging PowerPoint and accompanying differentiated resources have been designed to cover point 5.1 (i) as detailed in the Edexcel A-level Biology B specification and includes the phosphorylation of glucose, the breakdown to glycerate-3-phosphate and the subsequent oxidation to produce ATP and the reduced coenzyme. The lesson begins with the introduction of the name of the stage and then explains how the phosphorylation of the monosaccharides, the breakdown into GP and the production of the ATP, reduced coenzymes and pyruvate are the stages that need to be known for this specification. Time is taken to go through each of these stages and key points such as the use of ATP in phosphorylation are explained so that students can understand how this affects the net yield. A quick quiz competition is used to introduce NAD and the students will learn that the reduction of this coenzyme, which is followed by the transport of the protons and electrons to the cristae for the electron transport chain is critical for the overall production of ATP. Understanding checks, in a range of forms, are included throughout the lesson so that students can assess their progress and any misconceptions are immediately addressed.

This lesson has been designed to cover the content of specification point 4.1.2.1 (Chromosomes) and 4.1.2.2 (Mitosis and the cell cycle) of the AQA GCSE Biology and Combined Science course. Cell division is a topic which can cause students a number of problems so this lesson has been designed to ensure that the key details are covered and checked constantly. As well as the understanding and previous knowledge checks, quiz competitions are written into the lesson to maintain engagement and motivation. The lesson begins with the introduction of the term cell cycle and students will learn that the cycle consists of three stages. The key details of each of these stages is covered during the main part of the lesson so that students can meet the specification requirements of being able to describe the main events. Time is allotted for discussion to encourage students to converse about important points such as what happens to the replicated chromosomes during mitosis to enable identical daughter cells to be produced. Opportunities are taken to make links to other topics such as animal and plant cells as students are challenged to recall the functions of some sub-cellular structures. The final part of the lesson involves a series of summary questions which challenges the students to not only recall content but also to apply to unfamiliar organisms and it is not until the final question that they will answer a question about the cell cycle in humans.

This lesson has been designed to cover the content as detailed in point 2.13 (The structure and function of the nervous system) of the Edexcel GCSE Biology & Combined Science specifications. Consisting of a detailed and engaging PowerPoint (38 slides) and accompanying worksheets, the range of activities will motivate the students whilst ensuring that the content is covered in detail. Students will learn how receptors, sensory neurones, the CNS, motor neurones and effectors are involved in the detection and response to a stimulus. There is a focus on the structure of the sensory and motor neurones and the presence of the myelin sheath in both of these neurones is discussed with relation to the increased speed of conduction. Students will understand that a synapses involve the diffusion of neurotransmitters and allow communication between neurones and they are briefly introduced to relay neurones but these are covered in more detail in the reflexes lesson. Progress checks are included throughout the lesson so that students can assess their understanding of the content and any misconceptions can be addressed whilst quiz competitions, like FROM NUMBERS 2 LETTERS and SAY WHAT YOU SEE, are used to introduce new terms in a fun and memorable way. This lesson has been written for GCSE-aged students who are studying the Edexcel GCSE Biology or Combined Science specifications but can be used with older students who need to know the key details of the nervous system for their A level course before taking it to greater depths

This lesson resource contains a engaging PowerPoint and accompanying worksheets, all of which have been designed to cover the content of specification point 2.5 (d) on the WJEC GCSE Biology specification. This specification point states that students should know the components of a reflex arc. This lesson builds on the knowledge from the previous lesson on the structure and function of the nervous system (2.5b). The lesson begins by challenging the students to come up with the word reflex having been presented with 5 other synonyms of the word automatic. This leads into a section of discovery and discussion where students are encouraged to consider how a reflex arc can be automatic and rapid despite the fact that the impulse is conducted into the CNS like any other reaction. Students will be introduced to the relay neurone and will learn how this provides a communication between the sensory neurone and the motor neurone and therefore means that these arcs do not involve processing by the brain. Moving forwards, the main task of the lesson challenges the students to write a detailed description of a reflex arc. Assistance is given on the critical section which involves the relay neurone in the spinal cord before they have to use their knowledge of nervous reactions to write a paragraph before and after to complete the description. As a final task, students will have to compare the structure and functions of sensory, motor and relay neurones. Although this lesson has been designed for students studying on WJEC GCSE Biology course, it is also suitable for older students who are studying reflex reactions at A-level and need to recall the main details.

This is a fully-resourced lesson consisting of an engaging PowerPoint and differentiated worksheets which have been designed to cover the content of point 2.5 (i) as detailed on the WJEC GCSE Biology specification. This point states that students should demonstrate and apply their knowledge and understanding of how type I and II diabetes are caused and their respective treatments. There are links made throughout the lesson between this topic and the control of blood glucose concentration from specification point 2.5 (h). The lesson has been designed to take the format of a diabetic clinic where the students perform the duties of the attending doctor. They will move through the different stages of the role which includes identifying symptoms, diagnosis of type I or II and communication with the patients to reveal the findings. The wide range of activities will enable the students to learn how to spot that someone is suffering from diabetes and the similarities and differences between the different types so they can determine which one is being presented. The summary tasks challenge the students to construct a letter to a patient who is suffering from type II and to identify the correct type from another doctor’s letter. Understanding and previous knowledge checks are interspersed with quiz competitions, like the one shown in the cover image, which make the learning fun and memorable and enable the students to assess their progress. This lesson has been designed for students studying the WJEC GCSE Biology course but is suitable for both younger and older students who are focusing on this disease

This fully-resourced lesson has been designed to cover the content found in specification point 2.5 (f) of the WJEC GCSE Biology specification which states that students should understand why animals need to regulate the conditions inside their bodies. This resource contains an engaging and detailed PowerPoint (45 slides) and accompanying worksheets The lesson begins by challenging the student’s literacy skills as they are asked to recognise the key term, optimum, from 6 of its’ synonyms. Moving forwards, a range of quiz competitions are used to introduce the term homeostasis and to provide a definition for this key process. Students are given a newspaper article about water and blood glucose so they can recognise 2 conditions which are controlled in the human body. The next part of the lesson looks at the importance of maintaining the levels of water and glucose by considering the medical problems that could arise if they move away from the optimum levels. Students will learn that body temperature is also controlled and links are made to earlier knowledge as they have to explain why an increase in temperature above the set point would be an issue because of the denaturation of enzymes. The rest of the lesson looks at the three parts that are included in all control systems before a final quiz round introduces the receptors, coordination centre and effectors in the control of body temperature. As stated at the top, this lesson has been designed for GCSE-aged students who are studying the WJEC GCSE Biology course, but it can be used with A-level students who need to go back over the key points before looking at the process in more detail

This is a fully-resourced revision lesson that has been written to challenge students on their knowledge and understanding of the PAPER 2 topics. The range of tasks will prepare the students to answer the range of questions that they may encounter on topics B1 and B6 - B9 as detailed in the Pearson Edexcel GCSE Combined Science specification. The lesson has been designed to take place on the PAPER 2 HIGH STREET and the tasks include exam-style questions with displayed mark schemes, engaging quiz competitions and discussion points to allow the following points to be covered: Eukaryotic vs Prokaryotic cells Converting between units of size The structures of the animal and plant cells The structure of the human heart Calculating the surface area to volume ratio Adaptations of the gas exchange system The blood vessels associated with the human heart Calculating the cardiac output The features of the root hair cell to allow for absorption The nitrogen cycle The relationship between the rate of photosynthesis and light intensity and distance Using the inverse square law calculation Temperature and photosynthesis The regulation of blood glucose by the release of insulin and glucagon Diabetes type I and II Calculating the BMI The interaction of the reproductive hormones in the menstrual cycle IVF as assisted reproductive technology The hormonal and barrier methods of contraception Eutrophication as a negative human interaction in an ecosystem The carbon cycle In order to cater for the range of abilities that can be found in Combined Science classes, most of the tasks have been differentiated. There are also a number of step by step guides to demonstrate how to tackle some of the more difficult concepts including the mathemetical elements If you would like to see the quality of these revision lessons, download the PAPER 1 REVISION LESSON which has been shared for free

This detailed and engaging lesson describes the basic structure of a mononucleotide and the similarities and differences between DNA and RNA. The PowerPoint and accompanying worksheet containing exam-style questions have been designed to cover points 2.5 (i) & (ii) of the Pearson Edexcel A-level Biology A specification. In topic 1, the students were introduced to a number of monomers and the start of the lesson challenges them to recognise the key term nucleotide when only the letters U, C and T are shown. The next part of the lesson describes the structure of a DNA nucleotide and an RNA nucleotide so that the pentose sugar and the bases adenine, cytosine and guanine can be recognised as similarities whilst deoxyribose and ribose and thymine and uracil are seen as the differences. Time is taken to discuss how a phosphodiester bond is formed between adjacent nucleotides and their prior knowledge and understanding of condensation reactions is tested through a series of questions. Students are then introduced to the purine and pyrimidine bases and this leads into the description of the double-helical structure of DNA and the hydrogen bonds between complementary bases. The final section of the lesson describes the structure of mRNA, tRNA and rRNA and students are challenged to explain why this single stranded polynucleotide is shorter than DNA In addition to the current understanding and prior knowledge checks, a number of quiz rounds have been written into the lesson to introduce key terms in a fun and memorable way and the final round acts as a final check on the structures of DNA and RNA.

This fully-resourced lesson describes how Mycobacterium tuberculosis and human immunodeficiency virus infect human cells and cause symptoms. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover point 6.6 in unit 4 of the Edexcel International A-level Biology specification and ties in closely with the previous lesson where the structure of bacteria and viruses were compared. The lesson begins by ensuring that students recognise that TB is caused by the infection of a species of bacteria known as Mycobacterium tuberculosis and they will challenged to use their knowledge of scientific classification to recall that this pathogen is found in the mycobacteria genus. At this point, the students are told that the cell walls of this genus contain mycolic acids and later in the lesson they will have to work out that this specialist feature enables this pathogen to survive phagocytosis. A series of exam-style questions will challenge their knowledge of the respiratory and immune systems as they can understand how the bacterium travels to the alveoli where it is engulfed by a macrophage. Key terms like granuloma and necrosis are introduced and the sequence of events that occur following the formation of this aggregate of cells is described. The structure of viruses was covered during the previous lesson, so this next part of the lesson starts by challenging the students to recall the capsid, genetic material in the form of viral RNA and the lipid envelope. At this point, the students are introduced to gp120, the glycoprotein which is exposed on the surface of the lipid envelope, as this structure is critical for the entry of the virus into host cells. Students will annotate a basic diagram of HIV with these four structures which also has gp41 labelled. A quick quiz competition introduces the names of the enzymes found inside the capsid Moving forwards, the main task of this part of the lesson describes how HIV binds to the helper T cells, injects its capsid and integrates its DNA into the host’s genome in order to replicate to form virus particles (virions). Students are guided through the formation of a detailed answer about the mechanism of HIV and have to input key terms and structures where information is missing. Students will learn that the increase in the number of virus particles and a decrease in helper T cells and other immune cells results in infections like TB and by opportunistic pathogens and that this stage is recognised as AIDS

This fully-resourced lesson describes the role of memory cells in the secondary immune response. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover specification point 6.7 (iv) of the Edexcel A-level Biology B specification but also contains a detailed description of the structure and function of antibodies and therefore covers this part of 6.7 (ii) As memory B cells differentiate into plasma cells that produce antibodies when a specific antigen is re-encountered, it was decided to link the immune responses and antibodies together in one lesson. The lesson begins by checking on the students incoming knowledge to ensure that they recognise that B cells differentiate into plasma cells and memory cells. This was introduced in a previous lesson on the specific immune response and students must be confident in their understanding if the development of immunity is to be understood. A couple of quick quiz competitions are then used to introduce key terms so that the structure of antibodies in terms of polypeptide chains, variable and constant regions and hinge regions are met. Time is taken to focus on the variable region and to explain how the specificity of this for a particular antigen allows neutralisation and agglutination to take place. The remainder of the lesson focuses on the differences between the primary and secondary immune responses and a series of exam-style questions will enable students to understand that the quicker production of a greater concentration of these antibodies in the secondary response is due to the retention of memory cells.

This fully-resourced lesson describes how rod cells in the mammalian retina detect stimuli to allow vision in low light intensity. The detailed PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover the second part of point 8.5 of the Pearson Edexcel A-level Biology A (Salters Nuffield) specification and includes reference to the roles of rhodopsin, opsin, retinal, sodium ions, cation channels and hyperpolarisation in the formation of action potentials in the optic neurones. It is likely that students will be aware that the human retina contains rod and cone cells, so this lesson builds on that knowledge and adds the detail needed at this level. Students will discover that the optical pigment in rod cells is rhodopsin and that the bleaching of this into retinal and opsin results in a cascade of events that allows an action potential to be initiated along the optic nerve. Time is taken to go through the events that occur in the dark and then the students are challenged to use this as a guide when explaining how the events differ in the light. Key terms like depolarisation and hyperpolarisation, that were met earlier in topic 8, are used to explain the changes in membrane potential and the resulting effect on the connection with the bipolar and ganglion cells is then described.

This fully-resourced lesson describes the process of contraction of skeletal muscle in terms of the sliding filament theory. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover point 7.11 of the Edexcel International A-level Biology specification and includes descriptions of the role of actin, myosin, troponin, tropomyosin, calcium ions, ATP and ATPase. The lesson begins with a study of the structure of the thick and thin filaments. Students will recognise that the protruding heads of the myosin molecule are mobile and this enables this protein to bind to the binding sites when they are exposed on actin. This leads into the introduction of troponin and tropomyosin and key details about the binding of calcium to this complex is explained. Moving forwards, students are encouraged to discuss possible reasons that can explain how the sarcomere narrows during contraction when the filaments remain the same length. This main part of the lesson goes through the main steps of the sliding filament model of muscle contraction and the critical roles of the calcium ions and ATP are discussed. The final task of the lesson challenges the students to apply their knowledge by describing the immediate effect on muscle contraction when one of the elements doesn’t function correctly. This lesson has been written to tie in with the previous lesson on the structure of skeletal muscle fibre (point 7.10)

This lesson describes the transport mechanism of osmosis as the movement of water molecules from a high water potential to a lower water potential. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources are part of the second lesson in a series of 4 lessons which have been designed to cover point [c] as detailed in AS unit 1, topic 3 of the WJEC A-level Biology specification and also describes how cells are affected by this movement of water It’s likely that students will have used the term concentration in their osmosis definitions at GCSE, so the aim of the starter task is to introduce water potential to allow students to begin to recognise osmosis as the movement of water molecules from a high water potential to a lower potential, with the water potential gradient. Time is taken to describe the finer details of water potential to enable students to understand that 0 is the highest value (pure water) and that this becomes negative once solutes are dissolved. Exam-style questions are used throughout the lesson to check on current understanding as well as prior knowledge checks which make links to previously covered topics such as the lipid bilayer of the cell membrane. The remainder of the lesson focuses on the movement of water when animal and plant cells are suspended in hypotonic, hypertonic or isotonic solutions and the final appearance of these cells is described, including any issues this may cause.

This lesson describes the levels of organisation, including the aggregation of cells into tissues, tissues into organs and organs into organ systems. The detailed and engaging PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover point (d) of AS unit 1, topic 2 of the WJEC A-level Biology specification and focuses on the levels of organisation in humans and plants. Please note that the lesson does not contain prepared slides of tissue as this is covered in a later lesson. The lesson begins by using the process of haematopoiesis from haematopoietic stem cells to demonstrate how the red blood cell and neutrophil differ significantly in structure despite arising from the same cell along the same cell lineage. A series of exam-style questions will not only challenge their knowledge of structure but also their ability to apply this knowledge to unfamiliar situations. These differences in cell structure is further exemplified by the epithelial cells of the respiratory tract and students are challenged to remember how the shape and arrangement of these cells differ in the trachea and alveoli in relation to their function. The link between specialised cells and tissues is made at this point of the lesson so students are reminded that a tissue is a group of cells that work together to perform a specific function or set of functions. Moving forwards, a quick quiz competition will challenge the students to recognise the liver, kidney, spinal cord and pancreas from a brief functional description and this leads into a series of questions that links back to topics 1 and earlier in topic 2 where proteins, organelles and carbohydrates were originally covered. These prior knowledge checks are found throughout the lesson, along with current understanding checks, and all of the mark schemes are embedded into the PowerPoint to allow students to assess their progress. In terms of organ systems, a quick task challenges them to recognise 8 of the 11 that are found in humans from descriptions and this leaves them to identify the gaseous exchange, digestive and reproductive systems as the remaining 3. The remainder of the lesson focuses on specialised plant cells and the differing shapes and features of the palisade and spongy cells in the mesophyll layer and the guard cells are covered at length and in detail. The cells found in the xylem and phloem tissue are also discussed.

This lesson explains how a nerve impulse (action potential) is conducted along an axon and focuses on the role of the sodium and potassium ions. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover point 8.4 of the Edexcel International A-level Biology specification and contains detailed descriptions of resting potential, depolarisation, repolarisation, hyperpolarisation and the refractory period. This topic is commonly assessed in the terminal exams so extensive planning ensures that this resource includes a wide range of activities to motivate and engage the students whilst ensuring that the content is covered in the depth of detail that will allow them to have a real understanding. Interspersed within the activities are understanding checks and prior knowledge checks to enable the students to not only assess their progress against the current topic but also to challenge themselves on the links to earlier topics such as methods of movements across cell membranes. There are also a number of quiz competitions which are used to introduce key terms and values in a fun and memorable way and discussion points to encourage the students to consider why a particular process or mechanism occurs. Over the course of the lesson, the students will learn and discover how the movement of ions across the membrane causes the membrane potential to change. They will see how the resting potential is maintained through the use of the sodium/potassium pump and potassium ion leakage. There is a real focus on depolarisation to allow students to understand how generator potentials can combine and if the resulting depolarisation then exceeds the threshold potential, a full depolarisation will occur. At this point in the lesson students will discover how the all or nothing response explains that action potentials have the same magnitude and that instead a stronger stimulus is linked to an increase in the frequency of the transmission. The rest of the lesson challenges the students to apply their knowledge to explain how repolarisation and hyperpolarisation result and to suggest advantages of the refractory period for nerve cells.

This lesson describes the roles of the SAN and Purkyne fibres in the coordination of the three stages of the cardiac cycle. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources are part of the first lesson in a series of 2 lessons that have been designed to cover point [c] in topic 3 of AS unit 2 of the WJEC A-level Biology specification and has a specific focus on the pressure changes that occur in each stage of the cycle The start of the lesson introduces the cardiac cycle as well as the key term systole, so that students can immediately recognise that the three stages of the cycle are atrial and ventricular systole followed by diastole. Students are challenged on their prior knowledge of the structure of the heart as they have to name and state the function of an atrioventricular and semi-lunar valve from an internal diagram. This leads into the key point that pressure changes in the chambers and the major arteries results in the opening and closing of these sets of valves. Students are given a description of the pressure change that results in the opening of the AV valves and shown where this would be found on the graph detailing the pressure changes of the cardiac cycle. They then have to use this as a guide to write descriptions for the closing of the AV valve and the opening and closing of the semi-lunar valves and to locate these on the graph. By providing the students with this graph, the next part of the lesson can focus on explaining how these changes come about. Students have to use their current and prior knowledge of the chambers and blood vessels to write 4 descriptions that cover the cardiac cycle. This rest of the lesson focuses on the roles of the SAN and Purkyne fibres as well as the AVN and the bundle of His in the coordination of the heartbeat, continually linking back to the work on the cycle. The SAN is introduced as the natural pacemaker and then time is given to study each step of the conduction of the impulse as it spreads away from the myogenic tissue in a wave of excitation. Moving forwards, students are encouraged to consider why a delay would occur at the AVN and then they will learn that the impulse is conducted along the Bundle of His to the apex so that the contraction of the ventricles can happen from the bottom upwards. The structure of the cardiac muscle cells is discussed and the final task of the lesson challenges the students to describe the conducting tissue, with an emphasis on the use of key terminology.

This fully-resourced lesson describes the range of potential treatments for kidney failure. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover specification point (h) in topic 7 of A2 unit 3 of the WJEC A-level Biology specification. This lesson involves the diagnosis of a number of different kidney-related conditions and the potential treatments for kidney failure. This lesson is designed to get the students to take on the numerous roles of a doctor who works in the renal ward which include testing, diagnosis and treatment. Having obtained measurements by GFR and results by taking urine samples, hey are challenged to use their knowledge of the function of the kidney to study urine samples (and the accompanying GP’s notes) to diagnose one of four conditions. They then have to write a letter to the patient to explain how they made this diagnosis, again focusing on their knowledge of the structure and functions of the Bowman’s capsule and PCT. The rest of the lesson focuses on haemodialysis, peritoneal dialysis and kidney transplant. There are regular progress checks throughout the lesson so that students can assess their understanding and there are a number of homework activities included in the lesson.

This lesson describes the inheritance of two genes and guides students through the calculation of phenotypic ratios, before considering linkage. The PowerPoint and the accompanying resources have been designed to cover point [c] in topic 3 of A2 unit 4 of the WJEC A-level Biology specification. As the previous lesson described the construction of genetic crosses and pedigree diagrams, students are aware of the methods involved in writing genotypes and gametes for the inheritance of a single gene. Therefore, the start of this lesson builds on this understanding to ensure that students recognise that genotypes contain 4 alleles and gametes contain 2 alleles when two genes are inherited. The students are taken through the steps of a worked example to demonstrate the key steps in the calculation of a phenotypic ratio before 2 exam-style questions challenge them to apply their newly-acquired knowledge. Mark schemes are displayed within the PowerPoint to allow students to assess their progress. The phenotypic ratio generated as the answer to the next question is 9:3:3:1 and time is taken to explain that this is the expected ratio when two heterozygotes for two unlinked genes are crossed which they may be expected to use when meeting the chi squared test in an upcoming lesson The remainder of the lesson considers how linkage, where two genes have loci on the same chromosome, affects the outcome of dihybrid inheritance. This is a difficult topic which can be poorly understood by students so extra time was taken during the planning to split the concept into small chunks. There is a clear focus on using the number of parent phenotypes and recombinants in the offspring as a way to determine linkage and suggest how the loci of the two genes compare. Important links to other topics such as crossing over in meiosis are made to enable students to understand how the random formation of the point of contact (chiasma) determines whether new phenotypes will be seen in the offspring or not. Linkage is an important cause of variation and the difference between observed and expected results and this is emphasised on a number of occasions and a link to the chi squared test which is covered in an upcoming lesson is also made. The main task of the lesson act as understanding check where students are challenged to analyse the results of genetic crosses involving the inheritance of the ABO blood group gene and the nail-patella syndrome gene n humans and also the inheritance of body colour and wing length in Drosophila.

This lesson guides students through the use of a chi-squared test to determine the significance of the difference between observed and expected results. It is fully-resourced with a detailed PowerPoint and differentiated worksheets that have been designed to cover point (d) in topic 3 of A2 unit 4 of the WJEC A-level Biology specification The lesson includes a step-by-step guide to demonstrates how to carry out the test in small chunks. At each step, time is taken to explain any parts which could cause confusion and helpful hints are provided to increase the likelihood of success in exam questions on this topic. Students will understand how to use the phenotypic ratio to calculate the expected numbers and then how to find the critical value in order to compare it against the chi-squared value. A worked example is used to show the working which will be required to access the marks and then the main task challenges the students to apply their knowledge to a series of questions of increasing difficulty. This lesson has been specifically designed to tie in with the previous lessons in this topic as there are regular references to dihybrid inheritance as well as to topics in the AS units like meiosis

This lesson describes the structure of DNA as a double-stranded polymer coiled into a double helix and focuses on nucleotides as the monomers. The PowerPoint and accompanying resources have been designed to cover the detail of point 3.4 of the Edexcel GCSE Biology & Combined Science specifications. The lesson begins with a reveal of the acronym DNA and students will learn that this stands for deoxyribonucleic acid. There is a focus on the use and understanding of key terminology throughout the lesson so time is taken to look at the meanings of the prefixes poly and mono as well as the suffix -mer. This leads into the description of DNA as a polymer which is made up of many monomers known as nucleotides. Students will be introduced to the three components of a DNA nucleotide and will learn that four different bases can be attached to the sugar. An observational task is used to get them to recognise that DNA consists of two strands and that complementary bases are joined by hydrogen bonds. Understanding checks are interspersed throughout the lesson along with mark schemes so that students can assess their progress